So, I was obsessed with Neopets in Grade 6- until about Grade 9...
Over those years, I accumulated about 200+ toys and merchandise.
I had about 50 or so of the 6 inch plush toys, 125+ of the mcdonalds toys, 25 or so of the little vinyl figures, 3 of the big talking ones, 2 of the handheld deluxe "tamagotchi" games, all the magazines, many many cards and some other odds and ends like door signs and notebook paper.
I tried selling it all a few years ago, and ultimately ended up losing ALL of it when my ex boyfriend threw out all of my things when I went to Texas. It was a blessing in disguise- I had way too many toys for an 18 year old.